Saturday, December 1, 2007
RBRVS-For Primary Care No Good Work Goes Unpunished
The results are in - Medical Residents are not choosing to enter the Generalist fields of medicine in the United States. With current trends, less than 10% of those training in Internal Medicine will work as general internists. Compare this with JAMAs report that all European countries have a broad Generalist foundation comprising 70-80% of practicing physicians. The consequences of our failing primary care infrastructure will be higher costs, greater inefficiencies, lower quality, more uninsured and inability to get care even if you have insurance. If you think we have problems with financing health care now, you don't even want to see what is coming in the future!
In the U.S., current reimbursement substantially favors procedures and technical interventions and offers financial advantages for expensive care. This applies to all medical services, both hospital and physician. Hospitals are quietly closing routine care services all across the country in favor of specialty ortho (joint replacement, exotic spine treatment) and cardiac interventions. Routine obstetrics, pneumonia, diabetes and emphysema care are financial losers for the hospitals. The ever expanding preventions, vaccines, need for evaluation, counseling, talking with patients and guiding their health are financial losers for doctors.
What is the origin of these gross payment inequities? The Centers for Medicaid and Medicare Services (CMS) determines the reimbursement for professional services using a resourced base relative value scale (RBRVS). This complicated system is then adopted by health insurance payers also so it drives all reimbursement.
The committee that decides the value that determines $$ is called the RUC. It is made up mainly of specialists from the specialty societies. Only 3/30 seats have term limits. Specialties that account for a very small portion of all professional Medicare billing such as neurosurgery, pathology, otolaryngology, urology and plastic surgery sit in the seats that determine reimbursement. The proceedings are proprietary and are not publicly available for review.
This committee is a powerful force in the US medical economy. They create more and more incentives for specialty care and fail to accurately assess the practice expenses of primary care.
The new Medicare Part D drug benefit has created more non-reimbursed time and expense for primary care as they endeavor to match formularies for their senior patients. The RUC doesn't have a clue what it takes to practice primary care in America.
Residents are walking with their feet and who can blame them? The system is designed to get the result is is getting. Goodbye Primary Care! Hello expensive procedures and medical spas on every block.
We talk about universal coverage and health care reform without understanding that there will not be a solid base of physicians to deliver care to the population. A large portion of the population will not be able to have continuous and personalized care provided by Generalist physicians who have excellent clinical skills and good bedside manner. Having an insurance card (government or not) is not the same as receiving care.
Here is a remarkable feel good story as reported in the letters section of The New England Journal of Medicine. A 44 year old male n...
image from myaspiebrain Nothing like experiencing a medical condition first-hand to really help a doctor understand it from the patient...
Hey, I'm easing back into the blog world after a fun trip to NYC. If you are a Doctor or ever thought you'd enjoy the world of Med...
I love learning something new in medicine and this was a new one for me...black spot poison ivy. Poison ivy (also known as rhus dermatitis...